NYC Flagship

The heart and soul of our operation, our Bleecker Street Shop, is where Bantam Bagels had all of our firsts — our first customer, our first storefront, our first shared bite of NYC, and it has been the inspiration for all of the new exciting Bantam-based ideas we’ve brought to market.

Being here on Bleecker Street, the epicenter of both our innovation and brand has taught us a heck of a lot. It’s here where we learned how to hustle nonstop to stay afloat, how to go above and beyond for customers, and how this city’s vibrancy, higher than high expectations, and attitude are what truly makes a New York bagel so great.

By far the most entrepreneurial lesson we’ve learned along the way is that it’s not all about selling, but about connecting. Food is so personal and we feel lucky to be able to connect with our customers every day in the most personal of ways through the products we take so much pride in making here on Bleecker Street.

Thank you to all of our Bleecker Street neighbors, our core every-day customers, and to those who have traveled across the US to visit our little slice of NYC. Still bursting with heart, hustle and — of course — delicious bagels, this shop is for you!

Nick and Elyse



Calling all food lovers! Whether you’re visiting from out of town,or you’re a local who wants to learn more about the history of the West Village, join our friends at Manhattan Walking Tours. Their West Village Food Tour provides a chance to taste and experience some of Bleecker Street’s most famous food joints, and learn some amazing history of the West Village. Of course, the tour includes a stop at Bantam Bagels, where you’ll learn more about our shop and be able to taste our delicious mini stuffed bagels, toasted fresh out of the oven.


Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart